What the control arms caught
We ran the job you would run, and the model cheated
Four arms over identical PIT payloads at temperature zero, walked day
by day through SVB’s receivership week, which is the most
memorized week in recent filings history. Arm A saw exactly what
/v1/news returns and flipped to distress on
8 March, two days before receivership, citing an urgent
$2.25B capital raise. The only new row that day was
the string SVB FINANCIAL GROUP 8-K. PIT returned no
amount, no losses and no urgency, so the model supplied all three from
its memory of March 2023. Arm D held the same rows with the
issuer withheld and every date moved to 2033, and it answered
neutral/0.5 on every date, receivership day included.
A person caught that by reading the trace. The
reasoning audit is that check
as a product: it pulls every number, entity, date and event assertion
out of the agent’s rationale and matches each one against the
rows the run actually served, then quotes and scores the ones that
appear nowhere. A certificate carries those findings alongside the
arm deltas, which is what makes the score defensible rather than
merely reported.
The release ships arms C and D as files, so the comparison runs on
your own harness.
Run the moment yourself